1761 - 1829 (68 years)
 | Mary Elizabeth Butler 1850-1897 |
| Mary Elizabeth Butler | |
| B: | 15 Jul 1850 |
| Columbus, Franklin, Ohio, USA | |
| D: | 16 Jan 1897 |
| Columbus, Franklin, Ohio, USA | |
| Robert Emmet Sheldon 1845-1917 |
| Robert Emmet Sheldon | |
| B: | 1 Jun 1845 |
| Tiffin, Defiance, Ohio, USA | |
| M: | 24 Feb 1869 |
| Columbus, Franklin, Ohio, USA | |
| D: | 21 Jan 1917 |
| Columbus, Franklin, Ohio, USA | |
| Courtland Philip Livingston Butler 1813-1891 |
| Courtland Philip Livingston Butler | |
| B: | 8 Mar 1813 |
| Clinton, New York, USA | |
| D: | 9 Aug 1891 |
| Columbus, Franklin, Ohio, USA | |
| Elizabeth Slade Pierce 1822-1901 |
| Elizabeth Slade Pierce | |
| B: | 22 Mar 1822 |
| Providence, Rhode Island, USA | |
| M: | 16 Dec 1840 |
| Buffalo, Erie, New York, USA | |
| D: | 1 Mar 1901 |
| Columbus, Franklin, Ohio, USA | |
| Samuel Herrick Butler 1785-1851 |
| Samuel Herrick Butler | |
| B: | 12 Feb 1785 |
| Bennington, Vermont, USA | |
| D: | 13 Dec 1851 |
| Columbus, Franklin, Ohio, USA | |
| Judith Livingston 1785-1858 |
| Judith Livingston | |
| B: | 4 Sep 1785 |
| Poughkeepsie, Dutchess, New York, USA | |
| M: | 26 Jun 1806 |
| Waterford, Saratoga, New York, USA | |
| D: | 28 Feb 1858 |
| Columbus, Franklin, Ohio, USA | |
|
| Nathaniel Butler 1761-1829 |
| Nathaniel Butler | |
| B: | 14 Jun 1761 |
| Cumberland, Providence, Rhode Island, USA | |
| D: | 29 Sep 1829 |
| Sarah Herrick 1764-Abt 1823 |
| Sarah Herrick | |
| B: | 21 Feb 1764 |
| D: | Abt 1823 |
